| Platinum | Bewitched Aromas |
| Gold | Goddess Temple Canada |
| Silver | Bridgette's Garden |
| Bronze | Loshen & Crem |
| Top Pick | Alternative Cosmetics |
| Top Pick | Brosia's Brews and Witchy Shyt |
| Top Pick | Jack 59 |
| Top Pick | Niche Beauty |
| Top Pick | Ravn Collective |
| Top Pick | Tiffany Teal Collection |