| Platinum | Royal Pizza |
| Platinum | Tony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Versato's Pizza |
| Silver | Panini's Italian Cucina |
| Bronze | Pazzo Pazzo Italian Cuisine |
| Top Pick | Capital Pizza & Steakhouse |
| Top Pick | Coliseum Pizza & Steak |
| Top Pick | Franco's Pizza & Steakhouse |
| Top Pick | Lore Pizza |
| Top Pick | Lovepizza Heritage Valley |