| Platinum | Courtney Bakes Cookies |
| Platinum | Great North Cookie Co |
| Gold | Wishes Bake Shop |
| Silver | Bloom Cookie Co. |
| Bronze | Bon Ton Bakery |
| Top Pick | Bagel Bar |
| Top Pick | Confetti Sweets |
| Top Pick | Duchess Bake Shop |
| Top Pick | Karen's Kookies |
| Top Pick | The Farmhouse Bakery |