| Platinum | Rockin' Robyn's |
| Gold | Earls |
| Silver | Northern Chicken |
| Bronze | Black Viper Catering |
| Top Pick | Chop Steakhouse & Bar - Downtown |
| Top Pick | Commodore Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Hap's Hungry House |
| Top Pick | Joey's Restaurants |
| Top Pick | Panago Pizza |
| Top Pick | Saratoga Restaurant |