| Platinum | Serendipity Body Products |
| Gold | Bridgette's Garden |
| Gold | Three Fates Soap Co |
| Silver | Alternative Cosmetics |
| Bronze | Priaire Fire Soap Co |
| Top Pick | Bewitched Aromas |
| Top Pick | Niche Beauty |
| Top Pick | No Excuses - Perfumes for Less |
| Top Pick | Okt Lashes |
| Top Pick | Pura Botanicals |