| Platinum | Tikkhu Jewelry |
| Gold | Opal Creative |
| Silver | Hillberg & Berk |
| Silver | Yeg Mala |
| Bronze | The Plaid Giraffe |
| Top Pick | Evergreenly Handmade - Jewelry, Accessories, & More |
| Top Pick | Haiku Lane Jewelry |
| Top Pick | Maison Moonchild |
| Top Pick | Royce & Oak |
| Top Pick | So Pretty Cara Cotter |