| Platinum | Black Pearl Seafood Bar |
| Gold | Effing Seafoods |
| Silver | Grandin Fish 'N' Chips |
| Bronze | Blowers & Grafton |
| Top Pick | Codfadders Seafood |
| Top Pick | Joey's Seafood Restaurants - Terra Losa |
| Top Pick | Louisiana Purchase |
| Top Pick | SPLASH POKE |
| Top Pick | The Captain's Boil |
| Top Pick | Vons Steakhouse & Oyster Bar |
