| Platinum | Doughnut Party |
| Gold | Vi's For Pies |
| Silver | Bon Ton Bakery |
| Bronze | Scoop n Roll Creamery |
| Top Pick | Cookies By George |
| Top Pick | Dutch Delicious |
| Top Pick | Dutch Girl Cafe |
| Top Pick | Fuss Cupcakes |
| Top Pick | Sugar Bear Baking |
| Top Pick | Yelo'd Ice Cream & Bake Shoppe |
